Ratings / Privacy Law
Critical Rating 1 / 5 · Critical — Active surveillance / serious risk.
The UK Online Safety Act 2023, enacted on October 26, 2023, poses a significant threat to user privacy, primarily through its potential impact on end-to-end encryption. The Act grants Ofcom powers to require platforms to scan for illegal content, a technical mechanism that critic
The UK Online Safety Act 2023, enacted on October 26, 2023, poses a significant threat to user privacy, primarily through its potential impact on end-to-end encryption. The Act grants Ofcom powers to require platforms to scan for illegal content, a technical mechanism that critics, including major tech companies, warn could necessitate weakening encryption, as detailed in the Act's provisions under 'PART 7 OFCOM's powers and duties in relation to regulated services, CHAPTER 4 Information' (S0, S1). Furthermore, the Act mandates age verification or estimation for certain content, raising concerns about the collection of sensitive personal data, as outlined in 'PART 4 Other duties of providers... CHAPTER 1 User identity verification' (S0, S1). Despite government assurances in 2023 that these powers won't be used until technically feasible without compromising encryption, the provisions remain, creating a persistent risk to online privacy and security.
The full methodological and legal context for this rating. This card is what we point to when asked to substantiate the claim.