Sovereignware™ The sovereign AI operating system · archive of record

Ratings / App

Proton Pass

Clear   Rating 4 / 5 · Clear — Privacy aware. Generally safe.

Claim evaluated

Proton Pass is rated yellow due to its strong end-to-end encryption for all stored data, including passwords and notes, ensuring Proton AG cannot access content. Its privacy policy, last modified May 2026, explicitly states, "We do not have the technical means to access the conte

Analysis

Proton Pass is rated yellow due to its strong end-to-end encryption for all stored data, including passwords and notes, ensuring Proton AG cannot access content. Its privacy policy, last modified May 2026, explicitly states, "We do not have the technical means to access the content of your encrypted emails, files, calendar events, passwords, or notes," and aims to "collect as little user information as possible." The service underwent a commendable security audit by Cure53 in July 2023 and another by Recurity Labs between January and April 2026, which rated its security "well above par." However, Proton AG, based in Switzerland, is legally obligated to comply with valid Swiss court orders. This was demonstrated in 2021 when a Swiss court compelled Proton to provide a user's IP address, and in 2026, when the FBI obtained customer billing information via Swiss authorities, highlighting that while content is secure, metadata can be compelled.

Sources

Rating Grade Card

The full methodological and legal context for this rating. This card is what we point to when asked to substantiate the claim.

Rating IDark_intel_ae86c30d
SubjectProton Pass
CategoryApp
VerdictSecure — yellow
Beacon stateClear
Analyzed2026-11-12
CompanyProton AG
Privacy policy analyzedhttps://proton.me/legal/privacy
AnalystSovereign Beacon™ agent — Google Cloud Run · Gemini with Google Search, reads the subject's own privacy policy
ApprovalManual review before publication
Data basisPublicly reported information only
Claim framingOpinion based on cited sources, not a statement of intent
Ingest origingcp_beacon_agent
Content fingerprint5b2d88a715da73e9ccbc7c779199534d358a3867da9e1a865f3e7c466fb80b5e
Integrity proofHMAC-SHA256 recorded in the Node 0 attestation ledger (BEACON_RATING_COMMITTED) at commit
Right of replySubmit a response →
Disclaimer. This rating reflects publicly available information as of 2026-11-12. Conditions, policies, ownership, and product behavior may change after publication; re-verify before relying on this rating. The verdict expressed here is an opinion formed from the cited sources and is not a statement of fact about the subject's intent.